Equipment
Beginner

How to Choose Your First Guitar: Acoustic vs Electric

14 min read
Beginner Level

Complete guide to selecting your first guitar, including budget considerations and what to look for. Make the right choice to start your musical journey.

The Big Decision: Acoustic vs Electric

Choosing your first guitar is one of the most important decisions in your musical journey. The type of guitar you choose will influence your learning experience, the styles you can play, and your overall enjoyment. Let's explore the key differences and help you make the right choice for your goals and situation.

Acoustic Guitar: The Natural Choice

Acoustic guitars produce sound naturally through their hollow body and don't require amplification:

Acoustic Guitar Pros:

No amplification needed: Plug and play anywhere

Lower initial cost: No need for amp or cables

Great for songwriting: Perfect for composing and practice

Versatile styles: Folk, country, rock, pop, classical

Portable: Take it camping, to the beach, or anywhere

Natural sound: Warm, organic tone

Acoustic Guitar Cons:

Harder on fingers: Higher string action and tension

Limited volume control: Can't adjust loudness

Style limitations: Not ideal for metal or heavy rock

No effects: Can't use distortion, reverb, etc.

Size considerations: Full-size can be intimidating for small players

Electric Guitar: The Versatile Performer

Electric guitars use pickups to convert string vibrations into electrical signals, requiring an amplifier:

Electric Guitar Pros:

Easier to play: Lower string action, less finger pressure needed

Volume control: Adjustable from whisper to stadium levels

Effects capabilities: Distortion, delay, reverb, and countless sounds

Style versatility: Rock, blues, jazz, metal, funk, country

Comfortable size: Thinner body, easier to hold

Recording friendly: Direct input to recording interfaces

Electric Guitar Cons:

Requires amplifier: Additional cost and equipment

Cable dependency: Need cables, power outlets

Complexity: More knobs, switches, and settings

Less portable: Need amp and accessories

Practice limitations: Headphones needed for quiet practice

Budget Considerations

Your budget will significantly influence your options. Here's what to expect at different price points:

Entry-Level Budget ($100-$300)

Acoustic Options: Yamaha FG830, Fender CD-60S, Epiphone DR-100

Electric Options: Squier Classic Vibe, Epiphone Les Paul Special

What to expect: Playable instruments with decent sound quality

Compromises: Basic hardware, setup may need professional adjustment

Amplifier (Electric): Add $50-100 for practice amp

Mid-Range Budget ($300-$600)

Acoustic Options: Taylor Academy 10, Martin DX1AE, Yamaha FG850

Electric Options: Fender Player Series, Epiphone Standard Les Paul

What to expect: Better build quality, improved tone, reliable tuning

Features: Better pickups, solid wood components, professional setup

Amplifier (Electric): $100-200 for quality practice/small gig amp

What to Look for When Buying

Build Quality Checklist

Neck straightness: Look down the neck for warping or twisting

Fret condition: Smooth, level frets without sharp edges

Tuning stability: Guitar should hold tune after playing

Action height: Strings not too high off the fretboard

Intonation: 12th fret harmonic matches 12th fret note

Overall finish: No cracks, gaps, or rough spots

Sound Quality Assessment

Sustain: Notes should ring clearly and fade naturally

Balance: Volume should be even across all strings

Clarity: No buzzing, muffled, or unclear notes

Tone quality: Pleasant, musical sound at various volumes

Size Considerations

Guitar size can significantly impact comfort and playability:

Full-Size (4/4) Guitars

Best for: Adults and teens (age 12+) • Standard size for most players

3/4 Size Guitars

Best for: Ages 8-12, small adults, travel • Shorter neck, smaller body

1/2 Size Guitars

Best for: Ages 5-8 • Significantly smaller, easier for young children

Acoustic Guitar Types

Body Shapes and Their Characteristics

Dreadnought

Sound: Powerful, balanced tone with strong bass • Best for: Strumming, country, bluegrass

Concert/Grand Auditorium

Sound: Balanced, comfortable size • Best for: Fingerpicking, recording, versatile playing

Parlor/Travel

Sound: Intimate, focused tone • Best for: Practice, travel, smaller players

Electric Guitar Types

Popular Electric Guitar Styles

Stratocaster Style

Sound: Bright, versatile, three single-coil pickups • Best for: Rock, blues, pop, country

Les Paul Style

Sound: Warm, thick, humbucker pickups • Best for: Rock, blues, jazz, metal

Telecaster Style

Sound: Bright, twangy, cutting tone • Best for: Country, blues, indie rock

Essential Accessories

Must-Have Accessories for Any Guitar

Guitar tuner: Electronic tuner for accurate tuning ($15-30)

Guitar picks: Various thicknesses for different styles ($5-10)

Guitar case/gig bag: Protection for transport and storage ($30-100)

Guitar strap: For standing/performance ($10-25)

Music stand: For sheet music or tabs ($20-40)

Metronome: For timing practice ($15-30)

Electric Guitar Specific Accessories

Amplifier: Practice amp 10-20 watts ($50-200)

Guitar cable: 1/4" instrument cable ($10-25)

Headphones: For quiet practice ($20-50)

Effect pedals (optional): Distortion, reverb, delay ($30-100 each)

Where to Buy Your Guitar

Local Music Stores

Pros: Try before buying, professional setup, local support

Cons: Limited selection, potentially higher prices

Online Retailers

Pros: Large selection, competitive prices, customer reviews

Cons: Can't try before buying, shipping risks, setup needed

Used/Vintage Shops

Pros: Great deals, unique finds, character

Cons: Condition varies, limited warranty, expertise needed

Final Decision Framework

Use this framework to make your final decision:

Choose Acoustic If:

• You want to play folk, country, singer-songwriter styles

• Portability is important to you

• You prefer a simple, no-equipment approach

• Budget is tight (no amp needed)

• You want to focus on songwriting and composition

Choose Electric If:

• You want to play rock, blues, metal, or jazz

• Sound effects and experimentation appeal to you

• You prefer easier finger pressure

• You plan to play with others or perform

• Volume control is important for your living situation

made by stevebrowndotco